The share of the reproduction paper is based on analyses of as well as in insights into current methods and problems—plus the certainty that is added includes validating past outcomes.

  1. Relevance: Is this paper highly relevant to COLING?
  2. Readability/clarity: could be the paper well-structured and well-written?
  3. Data/code availability: may be the data/code (as appropriate) open to the study community or perhaps is here a compelling explanation offered why this isn’t feasible?